The Path Of Least Resistance
I wanted to share with everyone, these two brief episodes, both occuring today.
During AP Biology, in which I am an aide/lab tech, I was watching a lecture/discussion between Mr. Butler and his class, made up of mostly juniors. They were discussing evolution and why the issue is debated so hotly. One girl, whom we'll call Celina, did not act particularly engrossed in the discussion, so Mr. B singled her out.
"So what do you think about evolution, Celina?"
"Well," said Celina, with gum smacking and hair twirling in her voice, if not in her actions, "I just don't care."
Mr. Butler laughed. "That's a good camp to be in. There's this extreme, there's that. Celina is firmly in Camp Apathy. Good. For the sake of this class though, we need to care just a little bit."
Thinking she was being mocked, Celina became slightly defensive. "Well, I care enough to learn about it and pass the class, but I don't care enough to waste my life . . ."
Cutting her off, with a chipper tone, Mr. B said, "Good! That's the attitude to take."
In Journalism, I was leading a discussion/lecture on the chain of command of a newspaper, and the holes in our current system of organization. We are missing two editors currently, and at one point I asked for volenteers to fill in the ranks. One student, new this session, said, "Well, I looked at the paper last time before it went out, I just happened to see it, and I found like a million errors. It was really screwed up. So I want to be the one who looks over the whole thing and makes sure everything is right before it goes out."
I say to this kid, let's call him Duke. I say to Duke, "Well, Duke, that's the job of the editor in chief which is currently a position I hold. But if you'd like to be the editor, if you think you'd enjoy that, I'd encourage you to try it." I hold out the notebook I keep our records in to him.
Mrs. Williams shakes her head and says, "Now wait a minute, Jamie . . ." but I tell her that if Duke would be a better editor, if I allowed errors through, then who am I to stand in the way of our paper being the best it can be.
Up pipes a young protege of mine, Friedrich for now. Friedrich, in his righteous freshman indignation, fumes, "How dare you talk to her that way! She's our editor and . . ." but I cut him off and hush him. I say that the topic is open for civilized discussion. Did anyone want Duke to replace me as an editor? Did anyone think I was I failing in my responsibilities?
The room was silent. And it is still my newspaper.
I suppose what I'm trying to say is this: If a tree is tipping over, and you're the only thing holding it up, if you stop pushing against it and step out of the way, who falls?